March 26, 2007
BSG, RIP
This is a post about the Sci-FI TV show Battlestar Galactica. SPOILER WARNING: If you haven’t seen last night’s episode, stop reading until you have.
——
I’m sorry, they asked me to stay a loyal viewer through that dreadful ‘labor unrest on the ore processing ship’ episode, and the tedious ‘Detective Lee vs. the Black Market’ episode, and the mind-boggling awful Lee’s married to Dualla subplot, they think that a few minutes of ‘mysterious clues’ jammed into the end of an episode is supposed to hold me for NINE FRACKIN’ MONTHS?????
That’s not ‘organic’ scripting, that’s smokin’ dope.
Why should I bother ever thinking about this show again, much less tune in sometime NEXT YEAR? Especially now that I’ve seen they aren’t actually developing subtle plots over long time frames, but kinda pulling ‘cool stuff’ out of their butts? What’s my guarantee that, in 2008, there will actually be answers to the mysteries, and they will be worth waiting for? Nothing. I haven’t felt so manipulated for so little effect since X-Files.
Crazy Space Mom’s cancer is back at random. Riight. The Admiral throws his only surviving son out, but then decides, maybe not. And oh-lookee - there are only FOUR characters who think they are Cylons. Gosh, who’s the fifth? OOOhhh, very mysterious boys and girls. (Hey, doesn’t Chief have a kid? So that hybrid Hera’s not so special then, is she? And, um, hasn’t Tigh known Adama since before the first Cylon war, before ‘human form’ Cylons evolved? Let’s just rewrite everyone’s back story next season, shall we?) Oh look, that huge Cylon fleet that’s supposedly been chasing them has been waiting for them. Well, maybe at least we’ll find out what happened to all those on-board the Cylon ship plotlines they’ve dropped for weeks. Remember the virus, anyone? The in-fighting? The wacky babe in the bathtub? Probably not. That was all before they decided to put Baltar’s ’shocked’ face into a courtroom scene instead of the ‘end of 2001′ set. ‘Oh, were you actually paying attention and trying to follow a plot there? Sorry about that. We dumped it.’
Finally, ‘All Along The Watchtower’? Seriously? Perhaps the most egregious ‘you think there’s something meaningful here, but there isn’t’ lyric in Dylan’s entire ouevre?
Was that meant as a transcript from the latest writers’ session, trying to figure their way to another season? “There must be some way out of here, said the Joker to the Thief? There’s too much confusion, I can’t get no relief”? Now they’re just being insulting. What’s next, flying motorcycles visit LA? (uh-oh. Maybe so.)
Here’s a tip: if you’re asking viewers to come back to you some time NEXT YEAR after suddenly pulling the show out from under them, it would be smart to leave them with something other than “No reason to get excited, the Thief he kindly spoke.”
There are many here among us, who (now) think that Battlestar Galactica is but a joke.
